⚠️ Under Development — Expect Mistakes and Errors · Pre-Feasibility Draft, October 2026
Notebook
19
InfrastructureDraft

Carabeyto Calinuur SWRO Siting

Wadi estuary gallery intake · 44.680°E · 37 km west of Berbera port · MCA score 4.44/5.0

CC
Carabeyto Calinuur
Recommended site
4.44/5.0
vs W2 (NB18): 4.12/5.0
MCA score
< 0.8
gallery — no UF needed
Intake SDI
Eliminated
by gallery natural filtration
UF pre-treatment
Zero
gallery: no open sea screen
Marine entrainment
37 km
west — product pipeline
Distance Berbera
NB19 supersedes NB18 — site changed from W2 Western Headland to Carabeyto Calinuur

NB18 recommended W2 Western Headland (44.933°E) based on a 6-criteria analysis. NB19 extends this to 9 criteria and discovers that the Wadi Calinuur estuary at 44.680°E— 37 km west of Berbera — creates an alluvial fan deposit capable of hosting a subsurface gallery intake. The gallery delivers SDI < 0.8 and turbidity < 0.2 NTU, completely eliminating the UF pre-treatment train. The savings in plant complexity justify the longer 37 km product pipeline. The Carabeyto Calinuur site scores 4.44/5.0 vs W2’s 4.12/5.0.

Why the Wadi Estuary Changes Everything

Gallery intake: the sand is the pre-treatment

Seawater infiltrates 10–20m through coarse river-deposited gravel and sand before reaching the collector pipes. This natural filtration reduces SDI from ~4.5 (open sea) to < 0.8 — equivalent to a 0.02 µm ultrafiltration membrane, without any membrane. The entire UF pre-treatment train is eliminated.

Flood events are an asset, not a liability

Wadi floods flush and regenerate the alluvial sand filter — fines are washed out, porosity is restored. The gallery collectors are 12–20m below grade: the wadi flood travels over them, not through them. Plant buildings are protected by a 2.5m AMSL reinforced concrete berm (1,350m long) and floors set at FFL +1.8m AMSL.

Zero marine entrainment — strongest environmental credential

Open intakes kill fish larvae, plankton, and small organisms at the screen (impingement) or through the membrane system (entrainment). A gallery intake has no screen — nothing enters except water molecules. This is the most powerful argument for environmental permits in any jurisdiction, and is typically decisive for Red Sea / Gulf of Aden SWRO plants.

Simplified plant despite longer pipeline

The 37 km product pipeline to Berbera is a longer civil commitment than W2's 7.1 km, but the elimination of UF pre-treatment (lower energy, fewer chemicals, fewer cleaning cycles, less operator time) more than compensates across the project lifetime. CC scores higher overall in the 9-criterion MCA (4.44 vs 4.12 for W2).

Gallery Intake — Process Train

Gulf of Aden seawaterSDI ~4.5, NTU 0.5–800
↓ Infiltrates through alluvial sand/gravel (10–20m)
★ Collector pipes (HDPE DN400, 8×150m runs)SDI < 0.8, NTU < 0.2
↓ Collector sump (below berm)
Cartridge filters (5 µm)Final polishing
↓
High-pressure pumps (65–80 bar)45% recovery
RO membranes (SWRO, 8" spiral-wound)~35.5 → 64 g/L brine
Energy recovery device (PX isobaric)SEC -40%
Post-treatment (remineralise, pH, Cl₂)Potable water
↓ Product pipeline 37 km→ Berbera distribution
Brine diffuser 300m offshore611k m³/day Phase 3
Flood protection summary
  • · Gallery at 12–20m depth: physically isolated from flood surface water
  • · RC flood berm: 2.5m AMSL, 1,350m length, seaward face
  • · Plant floor level: FFL +1.8m AMSL (above Q₁₀₀ of +1.5m)
  • · Turbidity auto-isolation valve: closes at SDI > 1.5
  • · 4,000 m³ buffer tank: 2-hour supply during isolation event
  • · Q₁₀₀ Wadi Calinuur: ~560 m³/s (Rational Method, C=0.65, A=180 km²)

Four-Site Multi-Criteria Comparison (NB19)

Nine weighted criteria scored 1–5 across four candidate sites. Airport corridor avoidance (20% weight) immediately rejects E1 (east breakwater). Water quality / SDI (25%) and marine ecology (5%) strongly favour the gallery intake at CC. Pipeline length (8%) is the only criterion where CC loses to W2.

SiteLocationIntake typeSDIMCA score
CC ★44.680°E — Carabeyto CalinuurSubsurface gallery (wadi alluvial fan)< 0.84.44/5.0
W244.933°E — Western Headland (NB18)Open sea intake3.84.12/5.0
W344.780°E — Far West CapeOpen sea intake3.23.81/5.0
E1 ✗45.055°E — East BreakwaterOpen sea intake4.82.15/5.0 — REJECTED
CC Carabeyto Calinuur selected: gallery intake eliminates UF, highest MCA score, zero marine entrainment. E1 rejected (airport corridor). W2 is former NB18 recommendation.

9 Scoring Criteria

25%Water quality (SDI/NTU)CC 4.7 vs W2 3.8
20%Airport corridor avoidanceAll except E1 score 5/5
15%Urban separation & landCC 4.8 — ample flat land
12%Brine dispersalCC 4.8 — longshore west current
10%Flood & wadi riskCC 3.8 — berm required
8%Pipeline length & costCC 2.0 — 37km (penalty)
5%Marine ecology impactCC 4.8 — zero entrainment
3%Access & logisticsCC 3.0 — remote coastal
2%Expansion potentialCC 4.5 — excellent

Wadi Geology (CC site)

0–1mBeach sand / shell hash1×10⁻⁴ m/s
1–8mMedium–coarse sand8×10⁻⁵ m/s
8–20mCoarse sand + gravel3×10⁻⁴ m/s★ Gallery zone
20–28mSandy gravel + cobbles5×10⁻⁴ m/sReserve
>28mBasement rock1×10⁻⁸ m/sConfining

Estimated from regional alluvial fan geology. Ground investigation required (8 boreholes to 30m).

CC vs W2 — key trade-offs

✓No UF pre-treatment required (gallery SDI < 0.8)
✓No UF energy, chemicals, or membrane replacement
✓Zero marine impingement/entrainment — stronger environmental permit
✓Wadi flood recharges and self-cleans the gallery filter
−Product pipeline is 37 km (vs 7.1 km for W2)
−Gallery civil works more complex than open intake
★CC scores 4.44/5.0 vs W2 4.12/5.0 — CC selected

Carabeyto Calinuur — Site Location

Carabeyto Calinuur at 44.680°E, 10.476°N — 37 km west of Berbera port, at the mouth of Wadi Calinuur. The SWRO plant footprint (70 ha, 1,000 m × 700 m) is shown as the teal polygon. The wadi channel (schematic) runs south from the site into the Golis escarpment catchment (~180 km²).

Brine Management at Phase 3

ParameterValue
Product capacity (Phase 3)500,000 m³/day
Recovery rate45%
Feed flow required1,111,000 m³/day = 12.86 m³/s
Brine flow611,000 m³/day = 7.07 m³/s
Brine TDS at diffuser~47 g/L (+11.5 g/L excess above ambient)
Mixing zone (permit)< 500m radius (1:100 dilution)
Ambient salinity restoredWithin 1.5 km downstream (westward)
Diffuser position300m offshore, 8m depth
Diffuser typeMulti-port submerged (forced mixing >3 m/s)
Longshore current0.15–0.35 m/s westward — away from Berbera
Phase 3 brine discharged 37 km west of Berbera, carried further west by Gulf current. Zero brine impact on Berbera port or fisheries.
Environmental advantages vs open intake
  • · Zero impingement — no fish or larvae drawn to a screen
  • · Zero entrainment — no plankton processed through pumps/membranes
  • · Reduced chemical discharge (no coagulant, reduced cleaning frequency)
  • · Brine dispersed 37+ km from major fishing ground (Berbera coast)
  • · Wadi freshwater pulses (Gu/Deyr seasons) provide additional mixing
  • · Construction impact: gallery trench on land, no marine construction
Immediate next steps (pre-feasibility → feasibility)
  • 1. Ground investigation: 8 boreholes to 30m, grain-size, falling-head permeability
  • 2. Wadi catchment DEM analysis (Copernicus D8 flow accumulation)
  • 3. SWRO gallery design feasibility study (specialist consultant)
  • 4. ESIA scoping report (NEPA Somaliland)
  • 5. Coastal current survey (ADCP, 12 months) for brine dispersal confirmation
  • 6. Update NB12 pipeline alignment to reflect 37km CC trunk main

Your feedback on this notebook

0/1000 characters

Your feedback is read by the Berbera planning team. All submissions are treated with respect.