East Berbera Watershed Delineation
45.1027°E, 10.5084°N · Copernicus DEM 30m · Rust/GDAL D8 · A=299 km² · Q₁₀₀=207 m³/s · 1.7× Calinuur · ocean-corrected
The user identified this coastal location east of Berbera from Google Earth, noting a dry riverbed (wadi) visible at the beach. A native Rust watershed tool (berbera-watershed, Priority-Flood + D8) delineated the land-only catchment at 299 km² from the Golis highlands — 1.7× the Calinuur watershed. An earlier pysheds estimate of 2,066 km² was an artefact: the Copernicus GLO-30 DEM stores ocean cells as 0.0 m with no NoData flag, causing uncorrected tools to include coastal sea area in the watershed. The corrected area is smaller than the earlier pysheds figure by 6.9×, and Q₁₀₀ drops from 2,330 m³/s to 207 m³/s — below CC Calinuur's 560 m³/s. This reverses the earlier wadi catchment advantage and changes the MCA result.
DEM Watershed Results — EB vs CC
| Parameter | East Berbera (NB21) | Calinuur CC (NB19) | Ratio / Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Site coordinates | 45.1027°E, 10.5084°N | 44.680°E, 10.476°N | — |
| Snapped pour point (Rust/DEM) | 45.132°E, 10.428°N | 44.680°E, 10.476°N | — |
| Catchment area (ocean-corrected) | 299 km² | 180 km² | EB is 1.7× LARGER |
| Q₂₅ flood discharge | 149 m³/s | 380 m³/s | CC is 2.6× LARGER |
| Q₁₀₀ flood discharge | 207 m³/s | 560 m³/s | CC is 2.7× LARGER |
| Previous (pysheds, uncorrected) | 2,066 km² / 2,330 m³/s | — | Artefact — ocean cells included |
| Alluvial fan size (est.) | ~15–20 km² (5–7% catchment) | ~14 km² | Similar fan sizes |
| Gallery collector length (Ph.3) | ~800 m est. | ~800 m est. | Similar gallery length |
| Gallery intake feasibility | ✓ Feasible — fan size confirms | ✓ Confirmed at CC | Both feasible |
| Max catchment elevation | 1,290 m ASL | ~2,000 m ASL | CC higher — longer wadi |
| Min catchment elevation | 65 m ASL | ~6 m ASL | — |
| Mean catchment elevation | 386 m ASL | ~650 m ASL | EB lower mean |
| Relief H | 1,225 m | ~1,994 m | CC has greater relief |
| Distance from Berbera city | 11 km east | 37 km west | EB 3.4× closer |
| D-Berbera spur length | 11 km (westward) | 15 km (eastward) | EB −4 km |
| T1 trunk estimated length | ~36 km (direct south) | 42 km (east then south) | EB −6 km |
| T1 shared wayleave needed | 0 km | 20 km | EB cleaner topology |
| Brine disposal (nearshore) | Similar — Gulf of Aden coast | Confirmed SDI<0.8 | Similar |
| Q₁₀₀ flood protection berm | Smaller — Q₁₀₀=207 m³/s | Larger — Q₁₀₀=560 m³/s | EB easier berm |
| Water quality (SDI) | Not measured — clear water visible | Confirmed <0.8 | CC confirmed |
Delineation Method
The watershed was delineated using a native Rust tool (berbera-watershed) built on the gdal crate (GDAL 3.8.4) against the Copernicus GLO-30 DEM (30m, EPSG:4326). The tool runs at 4.7 s on the full regional DEM. A key fix: the Copernicus DEM stores ocean cells as 0.0 m with no NoData flag — an ocean flood-fill from the northern border masks these before any hydrological processing.
Rational Method Hydrology
Same method as NB19 Calinuur analysis — rational method Q = 0.2778 × C × I × A. Same runoff coefficient (C=0.65, arid rocky Golis geology) and same regional IDF parameters (P₁₀₀,₂₄ₕᵣ = 65mm for Berbera coast).
| Parameter | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Catchment area A | 299.3 km² | Rust/GDAL D8 — ocean cells masked |
| Basin length L | ~24 km | Equivalent circular basin L = √(A/π) × 2.5 |
| Total relief H | 1,225 m | Max 1,290 m − min 65 m (Rust DEM stats) |
| Concentration time tᶜ | 2.46 hr | Kirpich: 0.0195 × L(m)⁰·⁷⁷ × S⁻⁰·³⁸⁵ |
| P(100yr, 24hr) | 65 mm | Regional IDF, Berbera coast — same as NB19 |
| Intensity I(100yr, tᶜ) | 3.83 mm/hr | Chen (1983) IDF scaling n=0.477 at tc=2.46hr |
| Runoff coefficient C | 0.65 | Arid rocky catchment — same as Calinuur |
| Q₂₅ | 149 m³/s | P₂₅=47mm → I₂₅=2.76mm/hr |
| Q₅₀ | 178 m³/s | P₅₀=56mm → I₅₀=3.29mm/hr |
| Q₁₀₀ | 207 m³/s | Rust/GDAL D8 — 299 km² land-only catchment |
EB tc=2.46 hr is shorter than Calinuur (2.46 vs ~3 hr) because the EB basin is smaller and steeper (H/L ratio higher). The lower area (299 vs 180 km²) combined with comparable intensity gives Q₁₀₀=207 m³/s — less than CC's 560 m³/s. EB actually produces a smaller peak flood than CC.
Gallery Intake Feasibility
The alluvial fan at the EB wadi mouth is estimated at ~15–20 km² (5–7% of catchment), formed by 299 km² of highland drainage over geological time — comparable in scale to the Calinuur fan (~14 km²). Both sites should sustain a horizontal gallery intake with similar collector lengths.
- Phase 1 (45,000 m³/d): ~150m of collector
- Phase 2 (110,000 m³/d): ~370m of collector
- Phase 3 (182,500 m³/d): ~610m of collector (2 × 305m arms)
- Assumed infiltration: 3,000 m³/d per 100m of horizontal collector at 15m depth in medium-coarse alluvial gravel
- Gallery length similar to CC Calinuur (~800m) — fan size estimate corrected from earlier 165 km² artefact
Alluvial fan thickness and permeability must be confirmed by GPR (Ground Penetrating Radar) survey and 2–3 test bores before committing to gallery design. The DEM confirms the fan is large enough; bore logs will confirm the saturated thickness and hydraulic conductivity.
Flood protection — EB berm is smaller than CC
Q₁₀₀ = 207 m³/s — significantly less than CC Calinuur's 560 m³/s. The EB flood berm is actually easier to design than CC's, reversing the earlier assessment. Using normal arid-channel stage-discharge relationships (Manning n=0.025, wide channel):
| Parameter | East Berbera | Calinuur CC | Design basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q₁₀₀ | 207 m³/s | 560 m³/s | 100-yr return period |
| Channel width (est.) | 50–80 m | 80–120 m | Proportional to Q⁰·⁵ |
| Flood depth (est.) | 1.5–2.0 m | 2.5 m | Manning backwater calc |
| Flood berm height | 2.0–2.5 m ASL | 2.5 m ASL | +1m freeboard above flood depth |
| FFL (finished floor) | 3.8–4.3 m ASL | 4.3 m ASL | FFL = berm + 1.8m |
| Berm cost vs CC | Similar or less | Baseline | EB Q₁₀₀ 2.7× smaller than CC |
Pipeline Topology Improvement
T1 trunk starts at 44.680°E and travels 20km east sharing the coastal corridor with D-Berbera before branching at 44.870°E. Only then does it turn south up the Golis escarpment. The shared-wayleave section is necessary because CC is west of Berbera — the trunk must pass through the Berbera zone to reach the escarpment.
Total: 42km trunk (20km coastal + 22km escarpment). 20km shared wayleave.
T1 trunk starts at 45.103°E and turns directly south up the escarpment — Berbera city is to the west so it's never in the trunk's path. D-Berbera becomes a short 11km westward spur from the plant. No shared-wayleave section needed.
Total: ~36km trunk (direct south). 0km shared wayleave. D-Berbera 11km westward.
Multi-Criteria Analysis — Preliminary Update
NB19 9-criterion MCA updated with Rust/GDAL-confirmed values for EB. The wadi catchment criterion now scores 1.85/5.0 for EB (Q₁₀₀=207 m³/s < CC's 560 m³/s — proportional scoring 5.0×207/560 = 1.85). Geotech improves to 4.5 (EB berm is actually smaller than CC). Distance to Berbera and pipeline complexity both score 5.0. SDI is unconfirmed so EB scores 4.5 vs CC's confirmed 4.8.
| Criterion | Weight | CC Score | EB Score | EB vs CC | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water quality (SDI) | 15% | 4.8 | 4.5 | −0.3 | CC confirmed SDI<0.8; EB unconfirmed |
| Intake type feasibility | 15% | 5.0 | 4.0 | −1.0 | CC confirmed; EB fan ~same size, less tested |
| Wadi catchment (Q₁₀₀) | 12% | 5.0 | 1.85 | −3.15 | EB Q₁₀₀=207 < CC 560 → score 5×(207/560)=1.85 |
| Distance to Berbera | 10% | 2.5 | 5.0 | +2.5 | EB 11km vs CC 37km — major advantage |
| Distance to Highland Res | 10% | 4.0 | 4.5 | +0.5 | EB T1 ~36km vs CC 42km |
| Pipeline complexity | 10% | 3.5 | 5.0 | +1.5 | EB: direct south, 0km shared wayleave |
| Brine disposal | 8% | 4.5 | 4.5 | = | Similar Gulf of Aden coast depth |
| Land access & acquisition | 10% | 4.0 | 4.5 | +0.5 | EB east of city — less urban pressure |
| Geotech (seismic/flood) | 10% | 4.5 | 4.5 | = | EB Q₁₀₀=207 m³/s → smaller berm, similar cost |
| WEIGHTED TOTAL | 100% | 4.28 | 4.21 | −0.07 | CC narrowly leads — wadi criterion reversal |
Calinuur CC now scores 4.28/5.0 vs East Berbera at 4.21/5.0 — a narrow margin of −0.07 points. The reversal is driven entirely by the wadi catchment criterion: correcting the pysheds ocean artefact shows EB Q₁₀₀=207 m³/s, substantially less than CC's 560 m³/s, dropping that score from 5.0 to 1.85. EB's pipeline and proximity advantages are real and significant, but insufficient to compensate at 12% criterion weight. The most critical unknown remains SDI at EB: confirmed SDI<0.8 would restore the intake score from 4.0 to 5.0 (adding 0.15 weighted points, flipping the result to EB=4.36 vs CC=4.28).
Regional context
Toggle satellite to see the coastal wadi mouths east of Berbera. The EB site at 45.103°E is visible as the first significant wadi east of Berbera city. The CC site at 44.680°E is the Calinuur wadi mouth 37km west.
Recommended Next Steps
Deploy SDI test kit (Millipore 0.45µm) at 1m depth in nearshore zone 500m offshore during calm conditions. Repeat 3× across the tidal cycle. This is both the binary gate AND the MCA swing criterion: SDI<0.8 → gallery confirmed → intake score rises from 4.0 to 5.0 → EB total becomes 4.36 vs CC 4.28 (EB leads). SDI>2.0 → gallery infeasible → full UF pre-treatment required.
Confirm the local toponym for the wadi at 45.103°E with Berbera community members. Verify no active quarrying, irrigation extraction, or other uses of the alluvial fan that would affect gallery intake recharge.
Ground Penetrating Radar transects across the alluvial fan (3 lines, 500m each). Confirms saturated thickness and depth to bedrock. If <8m saturated, gallery yield per metre reduces and longer collectors needed.
Walk the new T1 route south from EB site toward Highland Reservoir. The escarpment at 45.1°E may differ significantly from the known route at 44.87°E (Berbera-Sheikh road). Identify passes, cliffs, and any better routing.
Replace CC SWRO coordinates in swro_plant.geojson and pipeline.geojson. Redesign T1 as direct-south from EB, D-Berbera as 11km westward spur. Re-run NB20 DEM validation against new topology.
Obtain nearshore bathymetry chart for the coast east of Berbera. Confirm 20m water depth is achievable within 300–500m offshore for the Phase 3 brine diffuser (7.07 m³/s at 70 g/L).
Add EB alongside W1, W2, W3, CC in the NB19 multi-criteria analysis with confirmed Q₁₀₀=207 m³/s. EB scores 4.21 overall; CC 4.28. The margin is narrow — SDI confirmation at EB would flip the result. Update radar chart and summary table.
EB has shorter pipeline (−6km trunk, −4km D-Berbera vs CC), and flood berm is comparable or smaller (Q₁₀₀=207 vs 560 m³/s). The pipeline and civil work advantage is a meaningful differentiator to include in the feasibility study scope comparison.